I built my whole brand around renovation. Nearly twenty years of buying, fixing, and selling homes, and I still believe the right renovation at the right time can build real equity. But I'm going to say something that might sound strange coming from the person people call the Renovation Real Estate Agent: renovation isn't the right move for everyone, and a lot of my buyers are better off going turnkey.
My job isn't to talk everyone into a project. It's to help you figure out which path actually fits your life, your timeline, and your tolerance for contractors showing up late. So let's talk honestly about both.
Why I Don't Push Renovation on Every Buyer
The numbers back this up. In a recent national survey, 62% of buyers chose a move-in ready home, while only about 28% went with a fixer-upper. Of the buyers who did take on a fixer-upper, nearly all of them, 98%, ended up making repairs after moving in, and more than 48% are now spending over $6,000 a year keeping up with it. More than one in five said if they could do it again, they'd skip the fixer-upper entirely.
Renovation takes cash reserves, time, patience, and a genuine appetite for decision fatigue. Picking tile is fun for about a week. If that's not the season of life you're in, there's no shame in that, and pretending otherwise wouldn't be doing right by you.
The Turnkey Premium Is Real, and Sometimes It's Worth Paying
Move-in ready homes typically sell for somewhere between 10% and 20% more than comparable fixer-uppers, depending on the market and how good the updates actually are. That premium isn't just paying for granite and new paint. You're paying for certainty. No permit delays, no contractor no-shows, no living through a kitchen demo with your kids. You're also paying for something lenders and insurers care about too, a move-in ready home is almost always easier to finance and insure than one that needs major systems replaced.
For plenty of buyers, that premium is worth every dollar. Peace of mind has a price, and sometimes it's the smartest money you'll spend.
Here's What Most Buyers Don't Know: Not Every "Renovated" Home Was Renovated Well
This is where it gets complicated, and it's exactly why I still matter to you even if you're set on buying turnkey. Flipping got a lot harder recently. Typical investor profit fell to around $65,981, down from roughly $77,000 the year before, the tightest margins in almost twenty years. At the same time, the typical flipped home today was originally built back in 1978, the oldest average vintage on record, which means investors are tackling older, more complicated houses while making less money doing it.
Put those two facts together and you get real pressure to cut corners somewhere. Sometimes that's fine, cosmetic shortcuts don't hurt you. Sometimes it's not, and the shortcuts are hiding behind fresh paint and staged furniture. Here's what I actually look for when I walk a flip with a client:
- Unpermitted work. Real electrical, plumbing, structural, or HVAC updates should have permits pulled. No permit usually means no inspection, and no inspection means nobody but the flipper ever verified the work.
- New finishes hiding old problems. New flooring over a damaged subfloor. Fresh paint over a water stain that was never actually addressed. Brand-new cabinets bolted over a plumbing leak nobody fixed.
- Sloppy workmanship. Cabinet doors that don't sit flush, grout that's already cracking, tile that sounds hollow when you tap it, trim that was just nailed up instead of properly finished. These are the tells of a crew moving fast, not a crew doing it right.
- New finishes next to an obviously old roof, water heater, or HVAC unit. Pretty surfaces don't mean the systems underneath got any love.
- A suspiciously fast turnaround. If a home was bought and relisted in under 60 days, ask yourself whether that's enough time to do the work right, because usually, it isn't.
This Is Exactly Where My Background Helps You
I've done this work with my own hands and my own money for almost two decades, so I know the difference between tile that was set right and tile that was rushed. I also spent years earlier in my career investigating mortgage fraud for a major bank, which means I was trained to notice when something is being presented as more than it actually is. That combination is unusual, and it's genuinely useful when you're standing in a beautifully staged kitchen trying to decide if what you're looking at is real quality or a really good photographer.
Whether you're touring a flip or a home that's never been touched, I'll help you pull permit history, ask the right questions about who did the work, and bring in an inspector who knows what to look for. You shouldn't have to guess whether you're paying for craftsmanship or just paint.
So Which Is Right for You?
If you've got the time, the cash cushion, and honestly, a little bit of patience for the process, renovation can still build real equity, I've watched it happen for my clients and for my own family more times than I can count. If what you want is to close, unpack, and get on with your life, turnkey is a completely legitimate choice, and I'll help you find one that's actually what it claims to be.
There's no wrong answer here, just the right one for where you are right now. Reach out and let's figure out which path fits you, and if turnkey is the move, let's make sure the one you buy is the real deal.
Joy Hicks, MBA, Realtor®
CLHA® - Certified Luxury Home Agent
SRES® – Seniors Real Estate Specialist
MRP® – Military Relocation Professional
HSR® - Home Stager and Redesigner Certified
RE/MAX Specialists
904.318.8619
hicks.joy@icloud.com
www.JoyHicksRealtor.com
Add comment
Comments